Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal Roofing: Pros and Cons for St. Louis Homes

What Happens If You Ignore a Roof Leak
February 4, 2026
For homeowners in St. Louis, Missouri, selecting the appropriate roofing material is a significant choice. Hot, muggy summers, torrential rain, high winds, hailstorms, and frigid winters are all common in our area. Any roof can be tested by that type of weather.

You’re not alone if you’re contrasting metal with asphalt roofing. These are two of the most prevalent choices recommended by roofing companies in St Louis and each has pros and cons of its own. In order to help you make educated choices for your home, we will evaluate the pros and cons of both roofing systems in this post.

The Significance of Roofing Selection in St. Louis

The weather in St. Louis is erratic. The lifespan of poorly selected roofing materials can be shortened by changes in temperatures, seasonal storms, and moisture deposition. To account for this, skilled roofing firms in St. Louis, Missouri, frequently stress choosing materials that can stand up to local conditions over just what looks inviting or is less priced up front.

Your roof has an impact on:

  • Protection of the home
  • Efficiency of energy
  • Costs of upkeep
  • Value of a property
Let’s examine the performance of metal roofing and asphalt shingles in St. Louis homes in more detail.

Asphalt Shingles: A Common Option for Homes in St. Louis

In Missouri, asphalt shingles are the most widespread sorts of roofing material. They are highly recommended by several St. Louis roofing businesses because of their price and adaptability.

Advantages of Asphalt Shingles

1. Economical Installation

One of the most expensive roofing materials is asphalt shingles. Shingles can be the preferred choice for homeowners looking to repair a roof without making an important upfront cost.

2. Simple to Replace and Repair

Even after storms or strong winds, repairs can be performed quickly and affordably by installing damaged shingles single at a time.

3. A Range of Colors and Styles

Although asphalt shingles can be purchased in an extensive range of hues and textures, homeowners may match the style they use for their roof to that of their house.

4. Reliable Performance

A great deal of St. Louis’ top roofing businesses have been building and taking care of asphalt shingle roofs for decades.

Drawbacks of Asphalt Shingles

1. Short Lifespan

a variety of quality and environmental exposure, asphalt shingles usually last 15 to 30 years. Storms in St. Louis may decrease that durability.

2. Sensitivity to Severe Weather

Over time, temperature fluctuations, hail, and strong winds can lead to granule loss, curling, or cracking.

3. Increased Long-Term Upkeep

When compared with metal roofing, more frequent inspections and repairs could be essential.

Metal Roofing: Constructed for Performance and Durability

Homeowners desiring long-term value are increasingly picking metal roofing. For homes exposed to regular storms, metal roofs are now advised by numerous roofing companies in St. Louis, MO.
Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal Roofing

Benefits of Metal Roofs

1. Outstanding Sturdiness

Metal roofs are some of the most enduring roofing materials available, with a lifespan of 40–70 years.

2. Superior Resistance to Weather

Metal roofing is perfect for St. Louis’s unpredictable weather and stands up to violent winds, hail, snow, and heavy rain.

3. Efficiency of Energy

When metal reflects heat, it keeps homes cooler throughout the summer and lowers energy costs.

4. Poor Upkeep

Metal roofs required fewer inspections and repairs as asphalt shingles.

5. Sustainable

A majority of metal roofs are recyclable and are typically built from recycled materials.

Cons of Metal Roofing

1. Greater Initial Expense

For some homeowners, the initial expense of metal roofing may be a deterrent.

2. Installation Calls for Experience

Working with knowledgeable St. Louis roofing firms is crucial since improper installation can cause problems.

3. Noise Issues (Uncommon but Potential)

Rain may sound louder without adequate insulation, however this is typically avoided with modern building techniques.

Is Asphalt Shingles or Metal Roofing Better for St. Louis?

Select asphalt shingles if you

  • Desire reduced initial expenses
  • Prefer a traditional look
  • Make plans to sell your house soon.

Select metal roofing if you

  • Desire durability over time
  • Make plans to spend decades in your house.
  • Desire less upkeep and energy savings

To suggest the best option, a reputable St Louis premier roofing company may assess your house, goals, and financial situation.

How Important It Is for Choosing the Right Roofing Company

Fixing the component accurately is vital regardless of what you choose. Poor construction is susceptible to leaks, damage to structures, and void promises.

Reputable roofing companies st. louis mo provide:

  • Licensed and insured professionals
  • Manufacturer-certified installers
  • Clear warranties
  • Transparent pricing
  • Local experience with St. Louis weather

Your roof will continue to function as intended for many years to come if you work with a reputable local contractor.

Why Horizon Roofing Is a Top Choice for Roofing in St. Louis, MO?

✅ Licensed & insured contractors
✅ Years of local experience
✅ Strong customer reviews and testimonials
✅ Manufacturer certifications
✅ Written warranties on labor and materials
✅ Inspections and honest roofing estimation

In summary, pick the right roofing investment.

Both roofing made of metal and asphalt shingles are excellent choices for St. Louis homes. Asphalt shingles offer low costs and an elegant look, while metal roofing gives unparalleled durability and long-term value.

You can make the best pick via being aware of your home’s requirements while working with competent St. Louis, Missouri roofing businesses that are experienced about the local climate.

Ready to Choose the Best Roof for Your St. Louis Home?

Don’t guess—get expert guidance from a trusted local professional.

👉 Schedule a Free Roofing Consultation with a St. Louis Premier Roofing Expert

Send Us Message

    blog author

    Brian Donohue

    Author

    Brian Donohue is the owner of Horizon Roofing & Exteriors, the leading roofing company in St. Peters, Missouri, dedicated to delivering quality roofing solutions. With a strong background in project management, sales, and customer service, Brian has built a reputation for reliability and excellence in the roofing and construction industry.

    MAKE AN APPOINTMENT

      This will close in 50 seconds