Can a 10–15 Year Old Roof Survive a Hail Storm?

hail damage old roof
March 21, 2026

What St. Charles & St. Louis County Homeowners Need to Know

One of the largest dangers of roofs in Missouri is hailstorms. You may be sitting there, and ask yourself, Can my roof withstand another hailstorm with this age of 10-15 years? Or is it time to replace it?

It will depend on a number of reasons such as age of roof, type of shingles, and hail size and past storms damages.

This question is particularly vital to the homeowners of St. Charles County and the St. Louis County since Missouri has several hailstorms annually, in which hailstones can be as large as to damage asphalt shingles.

The hailstones can be of various sizes and intensity. Hail can break shingles, loosen protective granules or cause cracks that allow penetration of water in due course when the hail hits on a roof.

Some common signs of hail damage include:

  • dents or impact marks on shingles
  • missing granules on asphalt shingles
  • cracked or broken roofing materials
  • soft spots or bruising on shingles
  • damage to gutters, vents, or flashing

Even small hail impacts may weaken roofing materials and lead to future leaks if not inspected.

⚠️ Is Your 10–15 Year Old Roof at Risk?

Your roof is more than 10 years old and your neighborhood was just hit by hail, so it might already have some damage on it that is not obvious.

It is unfortunate that many owners of the houses in the St. Charles County and the St. Louis County are unaware that their roof has been compromised until the days when they see leakage.

Horizon offers FREE hail damage inspections with no obligation.

✔ Fast local inspections
✔ Storm damage experts
✔ Insurance claim guidance

👉 Book your free roof inspection today before small damage becomes a costly repair.

How Hail Damages Older Roofs

Hail impacts roofs with tremendous force. When hailstones strike asphalt shingles, they can:

  • Knock off protective granules
  • Crack the fiberglass mat inside shingles
  • Bruise the asphalt layer
  • Create weak spots that later cause leaks

Even if your roof doesn’t leak immediately, damage can shorten its lifespan dramatically. In many cases, what was originally a 25-year roof may only last another 5–10 years after a major hailstorm.

This type of damage often goes unnoticed until months later when water starts entering the home.

hail damage old roof

Why Roof Age Matters During a Hail Storm

A roof that’s 10–15 years old sits in the “high-risk zone” for hail damage.

Here’s why:

Shingles Become Brittle

As shingles age, they lose flexibility. When hail strikes brittle shingles, they crack instead of absorbing impact.

Granules Are Already Worn

Granules protect shingles from UV damage. Older roofs already lose some granules over time, making them more vulnerable during storms.

Hidden Damage from Past Storms

Many Missouri homes have undetected hail damage from previous storms, which weakens the roof before the next storm even hits.

Missouri's Hail Risk Is Higher Than Many States

Homeowners in Missouri face unique weather challenges.

Missouri experiences 2–3 hailstorms each year, with many producing 1–3 inch hailstones capable of damaging roofing materials.

Recent storms in St. Charles County and St. Louis County have produced golf-ball to baseball-sized hail, which can severely damage standard asphalt shingles.

Even hail as small as one inch (quarter size) can cause roof damage depending on roof age and wind speed during the storm.

Signs Your 10–15 Year Old Roof Has Hail Damage

After a hailstorm, look for these warning signs:

Granules in Gutters

Large amounts of shingle granules washed into gutters after a storm.

Dents in Metal Components

Hail often leaves dents in vents, flashing, or gutters.

Dark Spots or Bruises on Shingles

These marks indicate granule loss and potential shingle damage.

Cracked or Missing Shingles

Severe hail impacts can fracture shingles or break them entirely.

Damage often appears scattered across the roof rather than in one location, which is why professional inspections are critical after hailstorms.

Repair or Replace? The 15-Year Rule

Roof age is one of the biggest factors when deciding between repair and replacement.

Typical guideline:

Repair may work if:

  • Roof is under 10 years old
  • Damage affects less than 25% of the roof

Replacement is usually recommended if:

  • Roof is 15+ years old
  • Hail damage affects multiple areas
  • Insurance approves replacement

Older roofs often reach a tipping point where patch repairs only delay larger problems.

What Homeowners in St. Charles & St. Louis County Should Do After a Hail Storm

If your roof is 10–15 years old, follow these steps after a storm:

  1. Document the Storm
    Take photos of hailstones and note the date.
  2. Check for Visible Damage
    Look for dents on gutters, siding, or outdoor furniture.
  3. Schedule a Professional Roof Inspection
    Many hail impacts are not visible from the ground.
  4. Check Your Insurance Timeline
    Most policies require claims within 12–24 months after the storm.

Free Roof Inspections in St. Charles & St. Louis County

If your roof is 10–15 years old and recently experienced a hailstorm, a professional inspection can determine whether:

  • Your roof is still safe
  • Repairs are enough
  • Insurance may cover a full roof replacement

A thorough inspection can identify damage early and prevent costly interior repairs later.

Schedule Your Free Hail Damage Roof Inspection

At Horizon, we help homeowners across:

Our storm specialists provide:

✔ Free roof inspections
✔ Insurance claim assistance
✔ Honest repair vs replacement recommendations

👉 Schedule your free inspection today before the next storm hits.

FAQ

Many homeowner insurance policies include storm damage coverage, but the final decision depends on the specific policy and the severity of damage.

Signs may include dents, cracked shingles, or missing granules. A professional inspection can provide a clearer evaluation.

If a storm produces large hail or strong winds, scheduling an inspection may help identify potential damage early.

Send Us Message

    blog author

    Brian Donohue

    Author

    Brian Donohue is the owner of Horizon Roofing & Exteriors, the leading roofing company in St. Peters, Missouri, dedicated to delivering quality roofing solutions. With a strong background in project management, sales, and customer service, Brian has built a reputation for reliability and excellence in the roofing and construction industry.

    MAKE AN APPOINTMENT

      This will close in 50 seconds